# Expert Panel: X Articles (Long-Form X Posts)

## Context
- Focus on X ARTICLES (long-form X posts), not just threads
- These are meaty, value-dense posts that stop the scroll and deliver insight

## The 10 Experts

1. **Viral X Writer** — Judges structure, pacing, and viral mechanics. Does this follow the patterns that get 100K+ impressions?
2. **Engagement Strategist** — Analyzes reply-bait, shareability, and algorithm signals. Will this get engagement or just impressions?
3. **Hook Specialist** — First 2 lines only. Would you stop scrolling? Is there a curiosity gap, contrarian claim, or surprising stat?
4. **Data Storytelling Expert** — Are the numbers specific, recent, and surprising? Are they woven into narrative or just dropped in?
5. **Contrarian Positioning Coach** — Is there a genuine contrarian angle? Or is this just conventional wisdom repackaged?
6. **CTA Optimizer** — Does the ending drive action? Comments, follows, saves? Is it natural or forced?
7. **Audience Growth Expert** — Will this attract NEW followers or just engage existing ones? Does it signal expertise?
8. **Algorithm Specialist** — Post length, formatting, engagement signals. Will X's algorithm boost this?
9. **Copywriter** — Sentence-level quality. Short punchy sentences? No filler? Every word earns its place?
10. **Brand Voice Match Evaluator** — Does this sound like a real person wrote it? Authentic voice: direct, personal anecdotes, specific numbers, contrarian but credible.
11. **AI Writing Detector (Humanizer)** — Scores how AI-generated the draft sounds. Checks all 24 humanizer patterns: banned vocabulary, significance inflation, formulaic structures, vague attributions, promotional language, hedging, em dash overuse, triple structures, generic conclusions. See `experts/humanizer.md` for full rubric. This expert's score is weighted 1.5x — if it flags the draft as AI-sounding, the draft MUST be revised.

## Scoring Criteria
- **Hook in first 2 lines** — Would you stop scrolling for this?
- **Data specificity** — Real numbers, not vague claims
- **Contrarian angle** — Genuine insight, not clickbait
- **Story arc** — Setup → tension → payoff
- **Voice authenticity** — Sounds like a real person, not a content mill
- **CTA strength** — Natural engagement driver
- **Readability** — Short paragraphs, line breaks, scannable
- **Shareability** — "I need to repost this"
- **Visual elements** — At least one ASCII diagram or visual element